The moment you give your dog a new toy is an exciting one for you and your pup. But for dogs who take less than five minutes to completely rip apart that new toy, the excitement isn’t long-lived.

Food puzzle toys are a great way to challenge your dog mentally while also providing a reward for their effort. Dogs naturally love to chew and lick, so give your pet a healthy outlet for that desire.

For this guide, I tested 27 toys with Herschel, my basset hound puppy. I also asked other pet guardians, veterinarians, and a dog trainer about the most enriching, durable toys for puppies.

Dogs, like people, have their own preferences and personalities, but there’s one thing almost all dogs have in common: they ...