Will Cuylle, who lost out on a goal earlier in the game due to a goalie interference call and was in the middle of the action all night, sent the game to overtime by scoring with 7:04 left in regulation, but Clayton Keller finished the Rangers off by scoring with 54.9 seconds remaining in OT.

In the end, the Utah Hockey Club, making its first visit to Madison Square Garden after moving from Arizona to Salt Lake City, stunned the Rangers on a goal by Clayton Keller with 54.9 seconds left in overtime, to win, 6-5, for third victory in three games this season.

On Saturday night, during the second period between Utah HC and the Rangers, multiple fights would break out after a scrum in front of the net completely broke down and the officials on the ice briefly lost control of the game.