The moment you give your dog a new toy is an exciting one for you and your pup. But for dogs who take less than five minutes to completely rip apart that new toy, the excitement isn’t long-lived.

For this guide, I tested 27 toys with Herschel, my basset hound puppy. I also asked other pet guardians, veterinarians, and a dog trainer about the most enriching, durable toys for puppies.

Consider Your Dog’s Size and Breed: Different dogs have varying play styles and jaw strengths. Choose appropriately sized ...