Austin was able to trace the recipe back to a Mrs.Craig, who lost her life during the hurricane of 1935. Nancy Slusser shared this recipe with us, noting that it is her favorite Key lime pie ...

Ask any Floridian how they like their key lime ... pie at Key Largo's landmark Mrs. Mac's Kitchen-which Keys Weekly has repeatedly named the best in the Upper Keys-leans toward indulgence, with a ...

Recipe courtesy of Camille Noe Pagan of SvelteGourmand. Ingredients: 1 (14 oz.) can fat-free sweetened condensed milk. 1 (8 oz.) package of reduced-fat or fat-free cream cheese, softened ...

The pie was likely invented in the mid-1800s, when sweetened condensed milk was more broadly distributed, said David L. Sloan, who wrote “The Ultimate Key Lime Cookbook.” Mr. Sloan said ...

So far, though, Sloan can only produce a local recipe for Key lime pie dated from 1939. Meanwhile, Parks, who consulted with local historians, didn’t find one from earlier than 1949.