Judge Greg Mathis has settled many disputes over the ... Far Too Tough Love Perhaps one of the show's most memorable cases, plaintiff Brandon Davis' case from 2003 brought the arbitrator to ...

“She was rotting in a trash can,” Kilgore said through tears during Tuesday's emotional sentencing of Brandon ... Davis confessed while at the Butler County Jail. Davis told the judge ...

The Butler County prosecutor said that Brandon Davis planned to ... my sister did not look like this.” Davis maintains his innocence and told the judge he was targeted by Middletown police.

But during a final hearing Tuesday, Brandon Davis said his constitution rights were being violated and continued to maintain his innocence in a loud statement after Judge Kelly Heile denied a ...