Jared Leto, now a pro at this, had yet another wild costume at the 2023 Met Gala in New York City on Monday (May 1). He dressed up like a cat. A big, fluffy white cat. But not just any cat!

"There's still pink in my ears," Earle tells PEOPLE at the 2024 CFDA Awards when discussing her Cheshire Cat Halloween costume that involved ... ahead to her next big bash: her birthday.