Making a stabbing motion with his arm, Madden told his family: “I’m responsible for what happened to her. I didn’t mean it. I love you,” Butler County Assistant Prosecutor Mike Hon said in ...

Madden has had several trial dates set, but found fault with a series of defense attorneys, both retained and appointed, causing delays in litigation. He has been disruptive in Butler County ...

Prosecutors say Madden, 54, stabbed the mother of his child, 50-year-old Rachelle Brewsaugh, 55 times inside their Hamilton home in October 2022. Butler County Common Pleas Court Judge Jennifer ...

Toby Madden signed a waiver to represent himself at his upcoming murder trial, but a Butler County judge would not sign off when the defendant repeatedly said he was “compelled” to be his own ...

Madden's trial that was set to begin Jan. 22 in Butler County Common Pleas Court was also cancelled after the Hamilton man allegedly made threats to assault his last defense attorney Brad Kraemer ...

Brewsaugh's longtime boyfriend, Toby Madden, has been in the Butler County Jail since last year, first on a drug charge then on a December indictment for her slaying. Madden, 51, was scheduled to ...

Jan. 8—Toby Madden signed a waiver to represent himself at his upcoming murder trial, but a Butler County judge would not sign off when the defendant repeatedly said he was "compelled" to be his ...